1959–60 Wolverhampton Wanderers 3–0 Blackburn Rovers Wembley Stadium
1960–61 Tottenham Hotspur 2–0 Leicester City Wembley Stadium
1961–62 Tottenham Hotspur 3–1 Burnley Wembley Stadium
1962–63 Manchester United 3–1 Leicester City Wembley Stadium
1963–64 West Ham United 3–2 Preston North End Wembley Stadium
1964–65 Liverpool 2–1 Leeds United Wembley Stadium
1965–66 Everton 3–2 Sheffield Wednesday Wembley Stadium
1966–67 Tottenham Hotspur 2–1 Chelsea Wembley Stadium
1967–68 West Bromwich Albion 1–0 Everton Wembley Stadium
1968–69 Manchester City 1–0 Leicester City Wembley Stadium
1969–70 Chelsea 2–2 Leeds United Wembley Stadium
(ulangan) Chelsea 2–1 Leeds United Old Trafford
1970–71 Arsenal 2–1 Liverpool Wembley Stadium
1971–72 Leeds United 1–0 Arsenal Wembley Stadium
1972–73 Sunderland 1–0 Leeds United Wembley Stadium
1973–74 Liverpool 3–0 Newcastle United Wembley Stadium